"A certain disciple turned to the Buddha with questions: — Teacher, before I begin to practise, I want to know: where does the world come from? Where is it going? Does the soul exist after death? What is the beginning of everything? The Buddha looked at him and told a story: — Imagine a man wounded by a poisoned arrow. His friends bring a physician, but the man says: 'I will not let the arrow be removed until I know who wounded me — whether he was a warrior or a priest, a merchant or a labourer. I will not let the arrow be pulled out until I know his name and his clan. Was he tall, short or of medium height? Dark, fair or ruddy? What village did he come from? Did he shoot with a longbow or a crossbow? What thread was the bowstring made of? What wood was the shaft made of? What bird were the feathers taken from?' — And what will happen to such a man? — asked the Buddha. — He will die from the poison before he learns the answers. — It is the same, disciple, with your questions. If you wait for answers to all the metaphysical riddles before you begin to practise, you will die before you find relief. One thing matters: to remove the arrow of suffering."
The "two arrows" model, or the concept of primary and secondary suffering, is an extremely practical idea that can significantly support both the psychedelic session itself and the integration process. It helps to distinguish between unavoidable suffering and the suffering we add ourselves. You can find this model in mindfulness-based programmes such as MBCT and in other Mindfulness Based Interventions.
The basics of the model
The first arrow (primary suffering) is the direct experience of what arises: difficult emotions, memories, unpleasant visions or feelings. It is a natural part of human experience that cannot be avoided. The second arrow (secondary suffering) is our mental stories about that experience: "This shouldn't be happening", "I'm doing something wrong", "This is dangerous", "I'll never get out of this". It is an additional layer of suffering that we create ourselves.
During a psychedelic session
In a psychedelic state, experiences can be, and usually are, especially intense. A psychedelic substance amplifies the intensity of a given experience. A sensation in the body may be more distinct, an emotion more intense, and a thought even closer to reality. Recognising the division into two arrows makes it possible to:
- Accept the first arrow as a natural part of the experience
- Release the second arrow: stop fighting with what is happening
Awareness of this can have a very large impact on the psychedelic process, because it can:
- reduce resistance and fear, which can intensify difficult experiences
- invite the cultivation of an attitude of curiosity instead of judgement
- teach us to stay present with what arises, without adding a narrative about whether it is "good" or "bad"
Of course, we need a similar approach most of all in everyday life, not during a psychedelic experience, and that is rather where all the magic should happen. In this sense, a psychedelic experience can show us the primary and secondary suffering more clearly, but really it is more about starting to notice it in everyday life.
In the process of psychedelic integration
After a session, difficult content often returns: memories, insights, emotional fragments. The two arrows model can be especially helpful here for increasing our awareness of how we live through experiences from the session.
Recognising the two levels
- The first arrow: what happened and what remains as a real experience (e.g. confrontation with fear, grief, loneliness)
- The second arrow: judgements such as "I shouldn't feel this way", "I ruined the experience", "others have beautiful visions and I only had suffering"
Benefits in integration
The two arrows model makes it possible to:
- Normalise the experience: the first arrow is part of human experience; we will not avoid it
- Disarm self-criticism: show that it is the second arrow that sustains suffering
- Redirect attention: towards acceptance, compassion and being with the experience as it is, instead of getting entangled in a narrative
Practical applications
Processing difficult moments of the session:
- Separating the fact ("I experienced intense fear") from the interpretation ("This means I am weak")
- Reducing shame and self-criticism related to the session
Application in everyday life:
- Recognising when we add unnecessary suffering to natural difficulties
- Practising presence with difficult emotions without immediate judgement
- Developing greater psychological resilience
The more aware we are of how we react to our inner experience, the more we can work with it. Sometimes we first have to notice how "sharp/judgemental and critical" we are towards ourselves in order to start working with this mechanism at all, and potentially with its aetiology. In the long term this can invite greater awareness and deeper insights. It is worth pausing here for a moment on the word "insight". It appears very often in various personal development groups of both secular and religious provenance and has become firmly part of everyday language. That is why I allow myself to keep this word and use it in the text you are reading. Using more professional, psychological language, we could speak of increasing awareness that happens at the level of thoughts, emotions or bodily sensations. Deepening insights:
- A better understanding of the mechanisms of how we live through inner and outer experiences
- Greater awareness of automatic patterns at the level of thinking and behaviour
- Reduced reactivity
- Building inner calm independent of external circumstances
Summary
The two arrows model (primary suffering/secondary suffering) can be valuable in a psychedelic context, because it provides a concrete map for navigating difficult experiences in the psychedelic process.
- It makes it possible to distinguish what is the experience and what is commentary on that experience.
- It makes it possible to notice how the way we respond to an inner or outer experience can lead to more pain, tension or suffering.
- It makes it possible to distinguish unavoidable life difficulties from those we add ourselves through resistance, experiential avoidance and ruminative processes
Increased awareness of the way we react leads to greater acceptance, self-compassion and more effective integration of psychedelic experiences into everyday life. And this particular aspect is the most important in all of this. Everyday life. Collecting new insights without change at the level of everyday life is really a road to nowhere. Of course, each of us, including the person writing these words, has had a share in walking such a road. Awareness does not always, and not immediately, translate into change. Sometimes the critical mass of awareness has to grow and become large enough for change to appear. Sometimes we need more favourable conditions and people around us, and then it is easier to invite change into everyday life.
A few thousand years after the Buddha, Freud wrote the following words to his colleague Wilhelm Fliess (1895):
"Where id is, there ego shall come to be. This is the work of civilisation. Analysis is only meant to free a person from their neurotic misery, so as to enable them to experience ordinary unhappiness."
No psychotherapy or other developmental activity will make us stop suffering (if someone promises you that, run the other way), but we can change our relationship to it. This is what Freud writes about, and this is what the two arrows model is about. It is not a tool, but rather an invitation to a completely different way of experiencing ourselves and the world around us. A way in which there can be more warmth, understanding and compassion, first for ourselves, and then perhaps for others.
Important. Please remember that the information in this post is for educational and informational purposes only. Psychedelics are powerful psychoactive substances, and their use carries a number of risks. They should be used only within approved clinical trials and under the strict supervision of qualified professionals. Many psychedelics are illegal in most countries. I do not promote or encourage their use outside a legal context. Always make sure that you know and comply with all local, national and international laws regarding the use and possession of controlled substances. The aim of this article, and of my activity in the area of psychedelic substances, is to increase awareness of the potential benefits and risks associated with the use of these substances in the spirit of harm reduction, and to translate good practice in psychedelic integration into the language of Gestalt psychotherapy.
Inspirations
- Examining the Potential Synergistic Effects Between Mindfulness Training and Psychedelic-Assisted Therapy
- Mindfulness meditation and psychedelics: potential synergies and commonalities
- Psychedelic-Assisted Psychotherapy and Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy: Potential Synergies
Photo: Canva



