Jakub Babij Book a meeting

Psychotherapy · · 6 min read

Separating without breaking up - on the need for separateness in a relationship

Machine translation. This article was translated from Polish by AI and has not been reviewed by a professional translator. Read the Polish original.

Agnes Cecile, “Life has been divided in two”
In this article
  1. "Create new rituals and new structures for your day. Ones that are not a continuation of 'shared life', but of yours."
  2. "Experiment with decisions that don't require consultation. Remind yourself what it is like to do something 'your own way'."
  3. "Check your needs and boundaries – they change."
  4. "Seek support, not solitude."

Sometimes it is good to move apart in order to be together....

If you don't know it yet, I recommend the SEXEDPL portal. It is a very good website devoted to sex education, human rights and a wide range of issues related to relationships.

Recently I came across a very interesting article there titled: "When there is no longer a 'we'. How to return to 'I' after a breakup?" – about how to recover yourself after a breakup. The article does not aspire to be exhaustive, but it shows what the path of rebuilding your self after separation can look like, and it does so skilfully. You will find the link below my post.

A breakup always confronts us with the experience of differentiation.

The longer and more symbiotic the relationship, the stronger the pain of "differentiating" can be. And although the end of every relationship is written into it from the moment it begins – in one way or another – sometimes the experience of a breakup is a natural consequence of the partner's/partners' lack of differentiation.

Often, paradoxically, it is precisely the lack of work on one's individuation, the blurring of the boundary between what is individual and what is shared, that leads to the greatest tensions and conflicts. Because where does "I" end and "we" begin? Where do we lose the figure of ourselves in favour of the unclear background of the relationship?

From a Gestalt perspective, healthy contact takes place at the boundary, which is at the same time a place of meeting and a place of separation.

If this boundary becomes porous, if we stop feeling what is ours and what is our partner's, we enter confluence – a state in which we lose the sense of separateness. This generates frustration, suppressed needs and, in the end, an explosion.

Of course, some amount of confluence is needed for a relationship to exist, but as the relationship goes on, and with a lack of mindfulness (and dozens of other mechanisms), boundaries can fade imperceptibly, but slowly and steadily.

That is why the points the author of the article lists in the context of returning to yourself after a breakup are, for me, the essence of healthy functioning as a couple for years before any breakup.

"Create new rituals and new structures for your day. Ones that are not a continuation of 'shared life', but of yours."

When we are in a relationship, we often merge into one. We forget about our solo pleasures, about a morning coffee in silence, about time just for ourselves. If we neglect our own "I" and its unique rhythm, we accumulate inner rebellion.

Make sure you have space just for yourself – your hobbies, your friends, your projects. This is not selfishness, it is mental hygiene.

In every relationship there are de facto three persons: me – the other one – us. Taking care of each of these figures is equally important, and there is nothing wrong with remembering yourself.

"Experiment with decisions that don't require consultation. Remind yourself what it is like to do something 'your own way'."

In a relationship we learn compromise, but we must not lose the ability to make decisions on our own. Sometimes try going for a spontaneous walk (or to some other event), buying yourself something "impractical", making a small decision that concerns only you.

On the surface this sounds like a small, insignificant activity, but such moves made while we are in a relationship are a continuous building of a sense of agency and a reminder of our own autonomy.

"Check your needs and boundaries – they change."

Needs are dynamic, boundaries evolve. What was OK a year ago may be unbearable today. I wrote "may", but actually I would like to write "should be".

I don't wear the same sweater as in primary school, I have learned to eat tomatoes, which I once didn't like, and it should be no different in a relationship. Movement creates flexibility, lack of movement creates rigidity. My behaviours, commitments and decisions should evolve if the fabric of my relationship is to be flexible. This is not some great philosophy or the heights of psychotherapy – it is ordinary common sense.

If you don't monitor your inner maps, if you don't communicate to your partner what is changing in your inner landscape (Jung would say: in the process of individuation, discovering further aspects of the Self), how are they supposed to understand you?

Staying in contact with your boundaries is the key to avoiding them being crossed, and the resulting resentment or aggression.

"Seek support, not solitude."

Yes, we should also look for support outside the relationship. A psychotherapist, friends, a support group – this is not betrayal, it is strengthening your own psyche. No partner should be our only source of support, because if they are, every crack in that supporting foundation will hurt/frighten us, wound us, or invite excessive control on our part.

If you have a ship that sails thanks to a single sail, a torn sail will always be a disaster on the scale of the Titanic.

Once, the whole village/community or tribe was a source of support; today we very often place all these functions in the person of our partner. Unfortunately, very often there is no chance that one person could carry all these functions without buckling under their weight. Maybe it won't happen right away, but over time the consequences will always come.

The stronger and more supported your "I" is, the healthier the "we" you can create.

Your partner should not be your only source of security and fulfilment. Relieving the other person of this role always takes pressure off the relationship and lets it breathe freely. A one-legged chair can support you and will look elegant, but a four-legged chair will always be more stable.

From a psychoanalytic perspective, a healthy relationship is one in which two mature, individuated persons (who have gone through the process of separation-individuation with their primary objects) are able to create closeness without merging.

It is the ability to be separate and at the same time connected – something that in object relations theory we call the capacity to use the object without destroying it through symbiotic fusion.

A lack of work on individuation – that is, on developing the fullness of one's Self, including conscious and unconscious aspects (Jungian integration of the shadow, dialogue with archetypes) – will always create tension in a relationship. Because what I do not integrate in myself, I will project onto my partner, burdening them with my deficits, unmet needs or inner conflicts.

What, in my view, is worth practising from the very beginning of a relationship is "separating without breaking up". If I have to recover myself right after a relationship, why not start doing it earlier?

This is not some utopian vision, but an everyday practice of taking care of your integrity while being in a relationship with another person. It is a constant balancing between "I" and "we". Finding room for your own breath, for your own voice and for your own space (however you understand it).

In my view, only by remembering ourselves can we truly be together with another person without losing ourselves in the process.


The article I refer to: Patrycja Wonatowska, "When there is no longer a 'we'. How to return to 'I' after a breakup?" (in Polish), SEXEDPL.

Painting: Agnes Cecile, “Life has been divided in two”

Would you like to talk about this in a session?

Book psychotherapy