Unfinished gestalt. On fulfilling needs and on how unfinished business can drag us down.
The drive towards closure
In Gestalt psychotherapy we hold that every being quite naturally wants to give its experience a complete shape. Myths and stories of the creation of the world begin with an idea, then slowly, through a period of hard work, move towards rest. In stories about heroes they make a superhuman effort in order to receive a reward at the end of the story.
We are the same. If you shape a cup out of clay, you will most likely not deliberately leave a big hole at the base. When you create a presentation, you will most likely not put four empty slides exactly in the middle. You will not start a training course only to walk out of it suddenly after a few minutes. Both in fairy tales and in reality we try to finish things. Finishing things gives them sense and meaning. So much for the ideal.
In Gestalt psychotherapy we use the term "unfinished business", though you may also find the phrases "unfinished gestalt" or "unclosed gestalt". We speak of it when, because of some obstacle or situation, you are not able to experience contact with what you want or need at a given moment. If the need is met, a feeling of relief, pleasure and satisfaction appears. The cycle can close, and perhaps after some time open again.
The problem appears when, because of internal or external obstacles, our need remains constantly unmet. Look at it as a glass of water. You are thirsty, but every time you want to drink, the cup falls out of your hand, the water turns out to be dirty, someone takes it away. You are still thirsty, you haven't had a drink for a long time, you grow weaker and weaker, your energy and desire to live drop. At some point the whole world around you may stop mattering. It makes no difference where you are or who you are with, because only your thirst is in the foreground. The "here and now" loses its meaning, because you are thirsty. Nothing and no one matters. There is only you and your unmet need.
The Zeigarnik effect
The so-called Zeigarnik effect describes this phenomenon very interestingly. It is the 1920s. The Russian psychologist Bluma Zeigarnik is sitting in a Viennese café, talking with her supervisor Kurt Lewin (the creator of the Gestalt field theory) and watching people. What she noticed intrigued her greatly. She observed that waiters remembered the content of unfulfilled orders much better than of those that had already been served, eaten and paid for. This meant that each waiter remembered very well who was still waiting for their dish, but once the customer had finished and left, he could not recall what he had served them. Bluma decided to investigate the subject in a series of experiments she carried out at the university. The research showed that activities whose completion had been interrupted were remembered much better and more strongly than completed ones. The Zeigarnik effect usually appears in the context of describing "procrastination". We will not stop at that station now, and will return to the subject of needs. Try to look at your brain as a computer system with a limited amount of working memory. According to the Zeigarnik effect, every unmet need will be remembered very well and kept in the field of your attention. The more open needs, or processes, the more your operating system will start to slow down. And this is not a metaphor. If you experience chronic tiredness, drowsiness, lack of energy, you can try to look at these symptoms as a signal. Perhaps your body is telling you something about your needs. Sometimes it can be the body's cry for less work, for better treatment. Sometimes it can be information about a need for closeness, a feeling of loneliness, or other needs that are only waiting to be looked at.
If Ms Zeigarnik were a contemporary scientist, she would have discovered something more. The brain remembers the negative better, and the positive and neutral less well. This is entirely normal from an evolutionary point of view: a human being has to anticipate danger. A person who does not anticipate it dies sooner. At least that was so for many thousands of years. As the neuropsychologist Rick Hanson says: "bad experiences stick to our memory like Velcro, and good ones slide off like oil on Teflon".
This does not make life easier for us. It means that we will very easily remember what is unfinished, and the more unpleasant it is, the more it will circle in the orbit of our attention.
How to close a gestalt
Meeting needs, or, as Gestalt jargon has it, "closing the gestalt", is possible only when we are aware of them. I know this is a truism and there is nothing groundbreaking in that sentence, but awareness of needs is not common. Parents do not always teach it ("you'll sit on that potty until you want to go"), school does not teach it ("you don't have to understand it, you have to know it"), nor does work ("no matter what, this has to be done by tomorrow"). Partners sometimes do not help either ("if you don't come with me to my mother's, it means you don't care about me"). In psychotherapy I work with the client on increasing awareness of their needs, of how they fulfil them or how they sabotage their fulfilment by following the same familiar paths. It is not always an easy process, but it is necessary in order to draw more satisfaction from life and from this ordinary, prosaic "here and now". You can look at it during psychotherapy, a mindfulness session or other activities that can widen your awareness. If you are not considering any of these options right now, that is also fine. To begin, you need a moment of silence and yourself. Below is a small exercise that may let you experience what is "unfinished" for you. Good luck!
A small exercise
Awareness
Sit comfortably, close your eyes and move your attention to your breath. Do not try to control it, do not try to change it. Just feel your breath. It may also be that you notice you do not feel it at all. That is fine too. That is how it is for you right now. However you feel about it, simply notice the fact of it. Notice whether any parts of the body move in rhythm with your breathing.
Choice
At some point thoughts will start to appear. Notice what kind of thoughts they are and what they are about. You can even give each of these thoughts a label: "planning", "analysing", "worrying", and so on. We do not need these labels in order to change anything, but in order to look at what is appearing. Notice whether these are frequent thoughts that you know. Notice whether emotions appear right behind the thoughts. Perhaps an emotion drags some sensation in the body along with it. Do you know these thoughts, do you know these emotions, do you feel what is happening in your body? How is it that out of a thousand things that could have appeared, it is precisely these that appear? Are they frequent guests in your home?
Avoiding
You can say to yourself the sentence "Today I am avoiding…" or "At this moment I am avoiding…" and see what sentences appear in your head. At some point the stream of sentences may disappear. Wait and ask yourself the same question once more. Notice whether the same sentences keep appearing, or whether there is something new. If nothing appears, just sit and focus your attention on how you breathe.
When you decide that you want to finish, move your attention to how you are sitting, to how you feel your body, especially the places that touch the floor or the back of the chair.
Bibliography
- Gestalt Therapy (100 Key Points), Dave Mann, 2010
- Awareness. Exploring, Experimenting, Experiencing, John O. Stevens, 1971
- Born to Win, Muriel James, 2017
- Procrastination, or the right moment always comes tomorrow



